A white background with a few lines on it

Your Value Prop Isn't Broken—You Just Don't Know Your Own Story

AJ Oberlender • May 22, 2025

Your Value Prop Isn't Broken—You Just Don't Know Your Own Story

You know what's frustrating? When you know your business delivers real value, but every time you try to explain it, you sound like every other company in your space.

"We provide comprehensive solutions." "We're customer-focused." "We deliver results."

Ugh. Even typing that makes me want to close the browser tab.

The problem isn't that you don't have a strong value proposition, it's that you're approaching it backwards. Most of us (myself included) start with what we think makes us special, then try to convince people why that matters.

But here's what I've learned running customer website projects at DoorLoop and building brands through Zossoz: your best value proposition is hiding in plain sight; in the success stories you've already created.

Here's the Thing About Value Props

Instead of brainstorming what makes you unique, start by looking backward. I call it the "Reverse Engineering Success" method, and it's way simpler than it sounds.

The idea is to study your most successful client relationships and identify the exact value they received. What specific problems did you solve? What measurable results did they achieve? Then, turn these real-world successes into your value proposition.

The Method That Actually Works

Grab your three most successful client relationships and ask yourself:

What specific problem did I solve for them?
Not the surface-level stuff like "we built them a website" or "we provided consulting." Dig deeper. Did you help them stop losing customers to competitors? Did you free up hours of their week? Did you help them finally feel confident about their brand?

What measurable results did they get?
This is where most people get squeamish because tracking results feels like work. But if you can't measure your impact, you can't sell it. Revenue increases, time saved, leads generated, customer retention, whatever applies to your business. Get specific.

What was different about how you approached their situation?
This is the secret sauce. Maybe you spent extra time understanding their industry. Maybe you caught something other vendors missed. Maybe you just explained things in a way that finally clicked for them.

Why This Beats Generic Positioning

Think about it this way: when you base your value prop on real results, you're not making promises, you're sharing a track record.

Instead of saying "We help businesses grow," you can say something like "We've helped X number of businesses increase their online sales by an average of Y% within Z timeframe through our proven strategy framework."

The difference? One is a promise anyone can make. The other is a track record only you can claim.

Your Turn to Reverse Engineer

Here's your homework (and yes, as a dad to two little ones, I'm comfortable assigning homework):

Step 1: Pick three clients where you absolutely knocked it out of the park.
Step 2: Write down the exact problem you solved and the specific results they got.
Step 3: Look for the pattern, what's the common thread in how you approach these challenges?
Step 4: Turn that pattern into a simple statement: "We help [type of business] achieve [specific outcome] by [your unique approach]."

Don't overthink it. The best value propositions feel obvious once you see them—because they're based on stuff that actually happened, not marketing fantasies.

The Real Talk Moment

Look, I get it. This feels vulnerable. You're putting real numbers and real claims out there instead of hiding behind safe, generic language. But that's exactly why it works.

Your success stories aren't just case studies, they're your competitive advantage. Most businesses are so busy looking forward that they forget to mine the gold that's already in their client relationships.

The companies crushing it in their markets aren't the ones with the fanciest websites or the biggest marketing budgets. They're the ones who can clearly articulate the specific value they've already delivered to real people.

Time to start treating your wins that way.


What's your best client success story? I'd love to hear about it. Drop me a line on LinkedIn—nothing makes my day quite like hearing about businesses that are absolutely crushing it.

Hands typing on a black keyboard, likely at a desk; wearing a jacket and bracelets.
By AJ Oberlender August 7, 2025
Discover how I automated entire Duda website content builds using Plumb AI workflows and ChatGPT prompts. Save hours while delivering custom property management copy that converts better than generic templates.
A woman is sitting on a desk in a lotus position with headphones on.
By AJ Oberlender July 23, 2025
Discover why authentic personal branding beats AI-generated content every time. Learn the 70/30 rule for using AI tools while keeping your unique voice and personality that connects with your audience.
A man with a beard and glasses is smiling in front of a pink background.
By AJ Oberlender July 13, 2025
A web designer's honest experiment with AI website builders. Discover what AI gets right, where it fails spectacularly, and why human creativity still matters in web design. Plus, why the "human in the loop" approach might be the future.
A woman is standing behind a counter in a restaurant holding a computer monitor.
By AJ Oberlender July 5, 2025
Discover how hospitality-inspired employee treatment delivers 300% ROI and 40% less turnover. From Ritz-Carlton secrets to Southwest Airlines success, learn the VIP strategies transforming workplace culture and employee engagement.
A man is holding a baby and two little girls on a sidewalk.
By AJ Oberlender June 27, 2025
Raising bold, compassionate, and fearless kids in today's world. A personal reflection on teaching my daughters the true meaning of chutzpah - not just being pushy, but having the audacity to care and the courage to make things better.
A little girl is sitting on a boat in front of a dolphins banner.
By AJ Oberlender June 17, 2025
Discover why sports fans spend 306% more than regular customers and how businesses like Apple, Netflix, and Patagonia are creating fanatic-level brand loyalty. Learn the psychology and strategies behind building devoted brand communities.
By AJ Oberlender June 12, 2025
Discover how the ancient Shema prayer became our secret weapon for meaningful bedtime connection. A Miami dad's guide to blending spirituality and modern parenting for better sleep and stronger family bonds.
A man wearing glasses and a hat is standing with his arms crossed.
By AJ Oberlender May 26, 2025
Discover the Story-Driven Contrast Method to build an authentic personal brand that cuts through the noise. Real strategies for entrepreneurs who refuse to sound like everyone else.
A row of buildings lit up at night with palm trees in front of them.
By AJ Oberlender May 13, 2025
Exploring the vibrant culture that inspires creativity and hustle. From Brickell to Little Havana, discover how Miami's unique energy creates the perfect storm for innovation and breakthrough thinking.
A collage of pictures shows a man holding a child
By AJ Oberlender May 5, 2025
A tribute to my dad, Brian Oberlender—VP, mentor, and morning coffee buddy. Lessons in grit, failure, and why being human is stronger than being a hero.
Show More